[mythtv-users] High end, state of the art Myth Frontend
Andre Newman
mythtv-list at dinkum.org.uk
Thu Sep 19 11:01:58 UTC 2013
On 19 Sep 2013, at 00:54, Jean-Yves Avenard <jyavenard at gmail.com> wrote:
> On 18 September 2013 20:12, Andre Newman <mythtv-list at dinkum.org.uk> wrote:
>
>> Is ffmpeg decode as good as vdpau or better?
>
> it should be the same... There used to be a time where VDPAU wasn't
> very keen on corrupted media, but things have changed for the better
> in the past few years.
> Having said that, there are still some corner cases where software
> decode will recover more easily.
>
>
>> My tests suggest it's similar but vdpau has some subtle noise reduction and cleaner scaling of poor SD material, maybe there are parameters to pass through to ffmpeg to improve decoding?
>
> The nice thing with vpdau is that you can use it for just the
> rendering / deinterlacing / denoising etc…
Yes, I have a profile just like you describe, I find this to be almost identical image quality to pure vdpau but of course ffmpeg plays 4:2:2 or 4:4:4 and just about manages 70Mbps mpeg2 and h264 unless it's single sliced.
The main difference is the edges of blocks are more visible in over compressed files and there seems more noise, I have deblocking turned on but maybe there are additional tweaks if the CPU can manage it.
> You go into mythfrontend setup , videos , playback and edit the
> High-Quality VDPAU playback profile. Change the decoder option to
> ffmpeg/software. Keep VDPAU for rendering.
>
> Increase the number of available CPU from 2 to 4….
I have a ffmpeg-vdpau profile instead of changing the vdpau one to make comparisons easier.
>
> then you'll have the best of both world: high quality post-video
> processing and stability of software decode
>
>>
>> How much CPU is enough CPU for h264 1080i50, 1080p decoding?
>
> you never have enough...
> I have a 3GHz i5, and I have some h264 samples where it almost struggle.
Can you send me some links to those samples, if they are out on the net somewhere, I'd like to have a datapoint of your 3Ghz i5 compared to my 2.8Ghz i7-860. which generation is your i5?
I was planning on a the fastest Haswell i3 a 4340, 3.6Ghz which seems a reasonable price and should be good for single sliced h264.
I haven't fully understood the graphics differences yet, I suspect that I need an i5 at least to get the high end haswell GPU. I'm happy to use the GT640 until the on board graphics matures.
Andre
More information about the mythtv-users
mailing list