[mythtv-users] TV Quality Recommendations (PVR-350 vs. S-Video vs. VGA->Composite)

devsk funtoos at yahoo.com
Fri Dec 29 19:33:27 UTC 2006

I have one very silly (even idiotic maybe) question. The three options accomplish different things. How do you hook up your cable TV to your PC with options 2 and 3? You say you are building first mythbox, and if you go with 2 or 3, I don't see you having a tuner in the picture to actually record or play any tv thru myth? then you talk about cable tv being analog only and its quality, which would mean you are routing cable thru your PC, which will require either a tuner or VIVO card. does fx5200 have VIVO?

If you are looking at only seeing what's on your PC monitor (like divx or h264 file playing with mplayer) on TV, then I would think 350 and 5200 is a waste of money. unless, I missed something really really obvious.


----- Original Message ----
From: Mike Hoover <ixarka at gmail.com>
To: mythtv-users at mythtv.org
Sent: Friday, December 29, 2006 10:47:53 AM
Subject: [mythtv-users] TV Quality Recommendations (PVR-350 vs. S-Video vs. VGA->Composite)

Hello everyone,

I'm putting together my first mythbox, and am doing a bit of research
on what components I'd like to put in the system.  I've read a lot of
posts on both this mailing list and others dealing with the issue of
picture quality on the TV from a mythbox compared to the original
quality of the picture when plugged right into the TV.  What I can't
find, however, are any screenshots or hard evidence of the quality
difference.  All I hear are anectodal descriptions of quality
differences from some,  others who claim that they don't notice any
difference, and still others saying that it was bad until they
downloaded some random patch that fixed everything.

With this issue in mind, I've narrowed my options to the following three:

1.  Purchase a PVR-350 and use it's TV-out.
2.  Purchase an FX5200 and use it's S-Video out.
3.  Purchase a VGA->Composite or similiar adapter and use my current video card.

I have regular old cable, not digital or satellite so the picture
quality isn't fantastic to begin with (but still crystal clear and

Does anyone have any advice on which of these three will result in the
best picture quality and just how much better that quality is than the
other options (ie, will I notice the difference on my 27" TV from 7
feet away)?  And, as always, if this issue has already been discussed
in another thread please point it out, since I couldn't find anything.

The only thing keeping me from purchasing the 350 right off the bat is
the myriad of problems I've read about this card including difficulty
getting X over the TV-out working (this is a MUST for me, since I plan
on watching divx videos as well), problems with the picture freezing
when fast forwarding/rewinding, various audio-out hassles, and a
general lack of support for the 350's TV-out capability since it lacks
OpenGL acceleration, especially in future versions of MythTV.

Any advice is much appreciated.
mythtv-users mailing list
mythtv-users at mythtv.org

Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://mythtv.org/pipermail/mythtv-users/attachments/20061229/3f30476d/attachment.htm 

More information about the mythtv-users mailing list