[mythtv] archiving to dvd
J. Donavan Stanley
jdonavan at gorpe.com
Sun Dec 7 08:29:27 EST 2003
Brent Hills wrote:
>On Sat, 2003-12-06 at 06:19, J. Donavan Stanley wrote:
>I like the idea of storing the metadata with the drive information. I
>would still like to keep the information in the database though so that
>you could easily determine what was archived without flipping through
I'd considered something like that myself. Something along the lines of
"Archived to MythDVD disk #11" in the database, along with a
corresponding "Please insert MythDVD disk #11" when you try to play an
achived recording. Such a feature would need to be optional though,
since one good reason to start archiving shows is to clear out your
recorded programs list.
>For me, I don't really need it to be in a "standard" dvd format. I need
>it to be in a format I can read via Myth and tools. Myth reads its own
>formats without the additional time and processing required to
>transcode. Just record and burn no additional processing required or
>worries about transcoding issues (audio/video sync,bad cuts, time and
>load to re-encode).
>If you maintain access to the cut list, bookmarks etc. its very
>versatile. I recognize there are others that would prefer it in a
>format they could more easily share with non-Myth friends or use in
>standard DVD players. For my needs, I will always be playing through
>Myth. As long as it can read it I'm happy.
I would also prefer the Myth specific DVD case, since you would be able
to fit more programs on the disk, if they were in MPEG 4 for example.
However, the ability to store the recrodings in a format playable on any
DVD player is compelling and has enough uses that I'd consider it a
"must have" for any itegrated archiving solution.
>Isaac and all have kept the file format relatively stable to my
>knowledge. I haven't worried too much about creating coasters I
>wouldn't be able to read in the near future. Is this naive?
Perhaps, but even if the file format changes there's always going to be
a way to play the older format.
>One issue with burning by the user interface is the need to have root
>privileges. I guess you could either allow sudo or prompt for a
>password to gain sufficient access.
As long as the device has it's permissions set properly you don't need
to be root to burn.
>I once stated that I was going to do a burn interface for mythmusic and
>have yet to spend enough time to fulfill that (and a few other
>suggestions I've opened my mouth for). So, I'll just keep shut this
>time, at least until my actions catch up with my mouth.
>I do find it encouraging that others might be interested in similar
>features and that this might become part of Myth's functionality rather
>than the manual work around I currently use.
I plan on starting on thius sometime around the first of the year... If
you've got any thoughts on it feel free to drop me a line off list.
More information about the mythtv-dev