[mythtv-users] Right then....how to tell recording to start xxx minutes in rather then at beginning?

John Pilkington J.Pilk at tesco.net
Wed Aug 3 22:50:02 UTC 2016


On 03/08/16 23:05, Mike Perkins wrote:
> On 03/08/16 22:32, John Pilkington wrote:
>> On 03/08/16 20:09, Another Sillyname wrote:
>>> The BBC are now showing the Olympics in a glorious 8 channel Red
>>> Button festival....I won't sleep for a month!!!!
>>>
>>> However I'll explain for non UK based users.
>>>
>>> The BBC Red Button service in effect turns digital channels on and off
>>> as required so if a certain Olympics event is due to start at say
>>> 14:00 the programming will start at say 13:45 and the channel will go
>>> live literally maybe a minute before the programming starts.
>>>
>>> In SD this hasn't usually created a problem.
>>>
>>> However in HD when you try to playback the recording has started
>>> early.....the HD decoder tries to play the file and borks (as the
>>> channel probably hasn't 'turned on' when the recording started), if
>>> you play the file with VLC it's fine...so it's there.
>>>
>>> I suspect that myth is looking for video info at the start of playback
>>> to decide what decode mode it needs to go into and when there isn't
>>> any it segfaults.
>>>
>>> So how can I tell myth to start playback say 4 minutes into a recording?
>>>
>>> I can't change the recording rules...there's far far to many
>>> recordings to want to mess around with (unless I can setup a rule such
>>> as "If this recording is on 'BBC RB HD' then start recording 5 minutes
>>> later then normal).
>>>
>>> Thanks
>>
>> I'm not sure I recognise the problem - but I normally use SD DVB-T, on
>> which the RB services appear
>> as normal EIT-schedulable channels 600 (RB 0) and 601 (RB 1), usually
>> at 544x576 resolution.
>> There's also 200 (Red Button), for which I don't see EIT data.  All
>> these are in the BBC SD mux.
>>
>> I don't see RB channels listed in the DVB-T2 HD mux.  mythffprobe on
>> BBC One HD currently shows two
>> dsmcc_b data streams with unsupported codecs, using current *buntu
>> ppa/trusty
>>
>> ...but no doubt things are different via HD DVB-S
>>
> The problem isn't that the channels are non-scheduleable but that
> because they come and go there often isn't even a carrier until just
> before the program begins.
>
> This is doubtless difficult for a tuner to cope with. We have this with
> BBC 4 which starts at 19:00 each evening (though doubtless it will be
> 24/7 during the Olympics). Because the channel isn't transmitting until
> just before startup time, it is difficult to record the first program of
> the evening without taking precautions.
>
Yes.  As you said, in SD it's usually possible to get decoding working 
by jumping forward, then creeping backwards.  But I also remember 
getting apparently blank recordings on the part-time kids' channels when 
the recording extended beyond the end-of-service;  haven't tried that 
recently.  Some form of transcoding used to fix it.


More information about the mythtv-users mailing list