[mythtv-users] High end, state of the art Myth Frontend

Joseph Fry joe at thefrys.com
Wed Sep 18 19:38:59 UTC 2013


>> Agreed!  They should have done away with interlaced with all HD
>> formats, there was no technical reason to keep it.
>
> Selective memory there?  There were some technical
> justification to keep it at the time that the standard was
> being decided (the '80s), although you may not agree
> with the reasoning (or the requirements), and I would
> agree that today some of those reasons are less
> convincing (partially as a reflection of 30 years of
> Moore's law and what you can put inside the box).

I disagree.  Interlacing made sense when phosphors on CRTs would dim
quickly and cause the picture to strobe.  By 1987, the VGA standard
was introduced which used 60hz progressive scan, so by then the
phosphors in CRTs were no longer an issue.

The only other argument for interlaced content is that it improves
motion over 30hz progressive.  But with 720p/60hz, you have a high
framerate for motion critical broadcasts.  I think they would have
been fine using 1080p/30hz as the format for standard broadcasts;
especially by the time that the ATSC standards were drafted (1995), as
by that time frame doubling with motion estimation/interpolation was
not unheard of.

>
> ....
>> Best is subjective anyway.  I have a hard time deciding if I like
>> feeding my TV a 1080p deinterlaced signal, or a a native 1080i signal
>> and letting the TV handle it.. the results are almost identical.
>
> That may simply be a reflection that you have a high
> quality TV (or, at least, someone put a high quality
> de-interlacing chip/core into your TV).  Some of the
> TV de-interlacers have been evaluated as quite good,
> some, terrible.

No, it's a Black Friday Walmart $199 special 47" Emerson.  I have a
feeling that it simply displays the interlaced picture, rather than
doing any sort of deinterlacing... but either way it's not bad for
most content.  I upgraded my system with VDPAU a few months back so
now I'm scaling everything to 1080p, but mostly because the OSD is
nicer that way.


More information about the mythtv-users mailing list