[mythtv-users] Unlocking Technologies Act
Joseph Fry
joe at thefrys.com
Fri May 10 03:49:53 UTC 2013
> Which leads to my favorite line from the congresswoman's summary is "In
>>> addition, the bill would permit the use and sale of tools – like
>>> software apps – that enable unlocking for uses that do not infringe on
>>> copyright. " I hope it's just a firmware update for the HDHR Prime to
>>> ignore the copy protection flags on cable channels!
>>>
>>
>> You could, but in all likelihood the firmware itself is copyrighted, and
>> thus you would not be able to distribute your modified versions of it. You
>> could (in theory) write your own clean room firmware from scratch, but then
>> you would still have to crack the CC handshake to authorize your new
>> firmware. If you have to deal with the handshake, you may as well do that
>> from their open source library, rather than trying to write a whole
>> firmware.
>
>
> Well at least someone seems to be trying to inject some sense into the
> DMCA. Is there any chance it will pass though? It's only a Bill at this
> stage from what I read.
>
Well, it does have some things going for it:
1. Two of the bills' creators are in CA... so they are willing to stand up
to the huge media lobby there.
2. It is a bipartisan bill to some degree.
3. It is actually a simple bill... anyone voting against it would have a
hard time finding a good excuse except that they are in big media's pockets.
4. It's a bill that voters of all types would support, and would be angry
if their representatives didn't... assuming they even knew what it meant.
5. It's timely... with high dollar smart phones dominating (even in low
income areas), even average folks are up in arms over the idea that they
can't take their phone with them to another carrier.
While I still have my doubts that it will pass, simply because the media
lobby is so strong, I will do what I can to promote it and get folks to
write their congressperson.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www.mythtv.org/pipermail/mythtv-users/attachments/20130509/86ac3287/attachment.html>
More information about the mythtv-users
mailing list