[mythtv-users] Why isn't LiveTV as smart as a regular recording?

[Michael T. Dean]

On 11/12/2008 04:17 PM, Phil Bridges wrote:
> On Wed, Nov 12, 2008 at 4:11 PM, Nick Rout wrote:
>> On Thu, Nov 13, 2008 at 9:34 AM, Jelle De Loecker wrote:
>>> I just want to ask for a bit of attention to a very old problem:
>>> For some strange reason, LiveTV can't switch the tuner automatically.
>>>
>>> <snip>
>>>
>>> I'm just wondering "Why is this so difficult?"
>>> When you record a show it WILL automatically choose the correct tuner,
>>> that's what makes it so great.
>>> I can choose to record 5 shows at once and the system will automatically
>>> choose the right tuner.
>>>
>>> Why, oh WHY, can't LiveTV!?
>>>       
>> simplest explanation - mythtv is not designed for watching live tv or
>> channel surfing.
>>
>> channel surfing is for people who don't know what they want to watch
>> and feel compelled to watch what the network wants to show them at the
>> time they are sitting in front of tv. Mythtv is for people who know
>> what they want to watch, and want to watch it when they feel like it.
> <top-posting corrected>
>
> *Sigh*.  If MythTV is not meant for watching LiveTV, LiveTV should not
> be an option.
>
> MythTV is also for the people like me that share 4 QAM tuners, 2 SD
> tuners, and 1 Firewire-equipped HD cable box to two televisions that
> don't have cable run to them.
>
> Despite the gnashing of the teeth that LiveTV is no different that
> scheduling recordings and immediately watching them, this is frther
> evidence to the contrary.

And any of these people are welcome to spend the time coding the support 
for what you all want out of LiveTV that MythTV currently lacks because 
the people who actually /are/ writing code for MythTV don't care to 
spend their time working on (presumably because they don't use LiveTV).

Or, put another way, no one who uses LiveTV seems to be writing any code 
to make it better.

Mike