[mythtv-users] limit the quantity of movies that get recorded

Tom Metro tmetro+mythtv-users at gmail.com
Thu Apr 24 21:32:21 UTC 2008


I find that I end up manually managing the quantity of movies I have 
recorded at any given time by adjusting the "inactive" flag on 
schedules, switching most to inactive once I've accumulated a bunch.

Is there a way to create a recording rule that will limit the quantity 
of movies recorded in a specified recording group, similar to the way 
you can limit the number of episodes that get recorded for a given 
recording rule?

Obviously the challenge is that each movie has its own unique recording 
rule, so the "number of recordings to keep" attribute doesn't do 
anything useful.

I'm guessing it may be possible to accomplish this with a power search, 
but unless a new UI was created to easily create power searches for 
movies, it would be a pain to have to create one for every movie.

(On a related note, I've noticed the "number of recordings to keep" 
attribute doesn't seem to have an effect when applied to a power search. 
At least not one entered via Mythweb.)

I know there are some side projects for managing movies, and I'd be 
interested to know if any of them address this problem.

Ideally, MythTV should have some special handling for movie schedules. 
In addition to the above functionality of letting you group together all 
movie schedules to apply attributes to them, it would also be nice if 
movie schedules automatically got deleted once the movie was deleted by 
the user or marked watched. And I'd like to be able to mark movies as 
"never watch" in a way that is distinguished from "never record"/"recorded."

Though I suppose a couple of more generic enhancements to the scheduler 
could accomplish the same thing. Like the ability to group together 
recording schedules, and an attribute to say a schedule was a "one shot" 
(different from a "one time") schedule.

A "movie manager" add-on to Mythweb would be another way to go. It could 
provide some of this functionality, such as generating power searches to 
implement the desired behavior, as well as a movie-centric UI for 
showing you just the upcoming films you haven't previously marked as 
"never watch" or "recorded."

  -Tom


More information about the mythtv-users mailing list