[mythtv-users] OT: Filesystems for recordings

Brian Wood beww at beww.org
Tue Nov 28 17:14:37 UTC 2006


On Nov 28, 2006, at 9:50 AM, Allan Wilson wrote:

> I am planning on rebuilding my mythbackend since I got in some new  
> hardware and I am planning on using LVM to span across a couple of  
> drives. I have 4 or 5 video sources through PVR cards and firewire.  
> I will have somewhere in the neighborhood of 1 to 1.5 TB of  
> storage. I was wondering what everyone would recommend for using as  
> the filesystem type for the LVM storage? Last go around I was using  
> XFS but I was wondering if there was something better to use  
> because of all the read/writes and large filesystem size. So what  
> do you think.
>

There is a lot of info on this in the list archives.

A lot of folks seem to think that XFS is the best because it can  
delete large files quickly, but that might be best for the video  
storage and not the operating system.

LVM does add some overhead to things, and might be a problem with  
slow systems, but shouldn't be with modern boxes.

Obviously RAID-0 will span across drives and increase transfer rate,  
but increases the likelihood of data loss due to drive failure.  
Linear "RAID" will span drives with better possibilities of  
recovering from a failure. RAID-5 has a lot of advantages but some  
CPU overhead to do in software, and RAID-5 hardware cards are expensive.

Everything is a tradeoff of the various parameters, you just have to  
decide what's best for you.

Personally I'm using a RAID-0 array with ext-3, I guess I like to  
live dangerously :-) Deleting any files of 1 hour or less doesn't  
seem to cause trouble but larger files will cause buffer overflows  
when the delete operation blocks and put glitches in any recording  
happening at the time. Hasn't been a problem for me though.



More information about the mythtv-users mailing list