[mythtv-users] GUI size vs. video size

Curtis Stanford curtis at stanfordcomputing.com
Mon Nov 24 18:48:45 EST 2003


On November 24, 2003 04:29 pm, Bruce Markey wrote:
> Bruce Markey wrote:
> > Curtis Stanford wrote:
> >> OK, I've seen messages about this before but I still think the
> >> situation stinks so I want to see want others think.
> >>
> >> I'm using an EPIA M10000 box with the latest VIA binary drivers for X
> >> windows. This driver has an overscan setting for use with TV's which
> >> works quite well. Of course, using this setting results in all the
> >> mythtv GUI stuff being cut off on all four edges. Adjusting the
> >> "Screen setting" (i.e. GUI width, height and offsets) fixes the GUI
> >> problem but screws up the video which was quite fine before thank you
> >> very much.
> >>
> >> My only choice seems to be to set the X driver to "underscan" and then
> >> try to adjust both the "Screen setting" options and "Overscan" options
> >> to try and get both the GUI and video to look right. After quite a
> >> number of tries, I never could get this to look right. Not nearly as
> >> good as letting the X driver to the overscan for me.
> >>
> >> So, why can't we have a setting to "inset" only the GUI so I can take
> >> advantage of the overscan setting in the X driver but still be able to
> >> see all of the GUI? Seems to be a much simpler solution, at least for
> >> other people out there in this situation.
> >>
> >> Thanks for listening.
> >
> > I listened and I feel your pain. I'm using nVidia TVOverScan
> > at 1.0 to try to align scan lines and am aware of the same sort
> > of problems. I imagine people using PVR-350s for TV-out are up
> > against the same thing. The main problems is that theme designs
> > are not aware of the NTSC "title safe" and "action safe" areas.
> > The secondary workaround/solution is that MythTV no longer has
> > a 'fullscreen' mode separate from the GUI dimensions.
>
> [Opps, hit the send button by accident. Sorry]
>
> Televisions are designed to deliberately overscan so that
> the picture fills the entire tube and edges won't be exposed.
> TVs, epically older ones, may not have stright edges and have
> rounded corners. The picture may not be exactly centered and
> the amount of overscan may vary. Therefore there is supposed
> to be an 'action safe' area 5% in from each edge and 'title
> safe' area 10% from the edge in broadcasts. This allows everyone
> to see anything important and read anything they are supposed
> to see on screen. Unfortunately, many pages on most MythTV
> themes push text right up against the edges. If you look at the
> menus for DVD players, VCR and DVRs they don't do this. They
> may have graphics that go off the edges of the screen but all
> text has plenty of border space.
>
> The GUI adjustments wouldn't be needed if the themes followed
> this standard. The GUI adjustments can compensate but even then
> there is a tight tolerance in trying to match the edges. Further,
> TV tubes have the most distortion and color convergence problems
> near the edge and text at the edges tend the highlight these
> problems.
>
> So, it would be nice if someone was kind enough to cobble
> together a theme with at least 5% border space on every page.
>
> Back in the olden days (earlier this year?) myth opened a
> different window for each page and the TV window was a separate
> window that could be toggled between GUI size and fullscreen.
> Until a recent update (my procrastination =), the HOW-TO
> described how to adjust the fullscreen TV and GUI independently.
>
> However, this multi window interface was annoying and Isaac
> did a fantastic job of putting everything in one window. The
> down side is that there is no longer a fullscreen mode. If
> there was a fullscreen mode, you could do exactly what you
> want, display TV in the full X display area then adjust the
> GUI to fit your TV.
>
> I started to look into this at one time but I don't know Qt
> well enough to figure out how to make it change dimensions
> when switching from the GUI pages to the Xv display.
>
> --  bjm

Thanks Bruce, this makes a lot more sense now :-) Time to work on a theme I 
guess....



More information about the mythtv-users mailing list