[mythtv-users] Re: OT: MUA statistics for this list

Justin Gombos mindfuq at fairfieldi.com
Sat Mar 19 06:09:04 UTC 2005


* Josh Burks <dotnofoolin at gmail.com> [2005-03-19 00:39]:
> 
> Whenever someone sends a message to the list, they send it to
> mythtv-users at mythtv.org. 

True.

> When you click the "Reply" button in any MUA on that message, guess
> what, you are replying to the list. 

Any button simply labeled "reply", and not "reply to list" or "reply
to group" is a personal reply on most MUAs (including Outlook).  The
reason clicking "reply" directs the message to mythtv-users at mythtv.org
is because the Reply-To field, which is for personal replies, has been
munged to contain the list address; effectively turning a personal
reply function into a list reply function, to compensate for those
MUAs lacking a list reply feature.

> So yes, just about every MUA has a list reply feature.

I doubt it.  Certainly Outlook and Outlook Express do not have a list
reply feature.  They only have personal reply (via the "Reply" button)
and group reply, and are not designed to account for mailing lists, or
have any knowledge of the Mail-Followup-To header.  Hence the
haphazard hack of hijacking the Reply-To field to duplicate the
purpose of the Mail-Followup-To field.


More information about the mythtv-users mailing list