[mythtv-users] Recording HDTV shows to DVD
Cory Papenfuss
papenfuss at juneau.me.vt.edu
Mon Jan 17 07:49:54 EST 2005
The reason you haven't found it is that it's a lossy conversion.
Most people who would want to archive an HDTV recording wouldn't want to
downgrade it to SDTV (i.e. 720x480). Since you asked, a few
clarifications:
> Along the way I've discovered that HDTV broadcasts are
> in a format called MPEG2-TS (transport stream) which
> differs from other MPEG2 files. Standard Myth tools
> such as nuvexport do not handle MPEG2-TS streams.
MPEG-TS is basically a wrapper for an MPEG-PS. I believe it's
got some additional packetization and other "Transport"-type doodads, but
the actual video stream is the same.
>
> Another wrinkle is that HDTV broadcasts are often
> 1920x1080i or 1280x720p, whereas the highest
> resolution allowed on a standard DVD is 720x480, so
> some resizing of the video will be necessary. Extra
> credit here for making an anamorphic DVD that retains
> the 16:9 format of the original broadcast.
Big wrinkle. Basically, it's not high-def once it's 720x480. You
will need to reencode the video to 720x480, losing quality to bother
resizing and another encoding genloss. Also, it'll take oodles of cpu
time... on a 2GHz machine, probably 5-10hours/hour for a good 2-pass
encode.
>
> HDTV streams carry AC3 audio, but DVDs have either AC3
> or MPEG audio, so it may be necessary to create a
> two-channel audio track for use on DVD-players without
> builtin AC3 decoding.
No. AC3 is more or less a wrapper as well. Somone correct me
if I'm a bit off on this, but MPEG audio in the DVD spec is MPEG1-LayerII.
AC3 is MPEG2-LayerIII (a.k.a. MP3) if 2-channel. If 5.1, it's different.
HDTV audio stream should be able to go through unmodified.
>
> I have found several Linux programs which can handle
> portions of the above, but nobody has yet created a
> set of instructions for how to use them to archive a
> broadcast to DVD. Did I miss the "Ultimate Guide to
> HDTV-DVD Recording" in my search?
Try avidemux for a fairly nice WYSIWYG cutting/transcoding
program. Feel free to take notes and write said missing guide.... :)
-Cory
*************************************************************************
* Cory Papenfuss *
* Electrical Engineering candidate Ph.D. graduate student *
* Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University *
*************************************************************************
More information about the mythtv-users
mailing list